2014 Milwaukee Brewers 25-Man Roster Projection

Milwaukee Brewers

We’re on the precipice of Opening Day, but there are still some decisions awaiting the front office staff of the Milwaukee Brewers.

Most pressing, if not most important, is how they will construct the 25-man roster to begin the 2014 regular season. In this, they’ve got some options.

Let’s assume a couple of things off the top here. First, a standard 13 hitter, 12 pitcher roster split. Second, that we’re all aware that things will change throughout the season and plenty of the players who don’t make the Opening Day roster will don a Brewers uniform at some point in 2014.

I’ll lay out the different roster groupings and then explain what went into my decisions thereafter. Cool?

With that, to the list!

Starting Pitchers (5)

  • Yovani Gallardo
  • Kyle Lohse
  • Marco Estrada
  • Matt Garza
  • Wily Peralta

I did my best educated guess at the order here too. It was announced that Gallardo has Opening Day honors and that Lohse will follow in Game 2. It was also hinted that Garza could pitch the opener in Boston, but that isn’t for sure yet…at least not publicly. Couple that with how well Estrada has pitched and he’s the superior choice against Atlanta in Game 3 than is Peralta.

The wrinkle here is that the Brewers have the opportunity to start the season with four starters because of the off-days scheduled. They don’t need a fifth starting pitcher until mid-April. If they do that, Peralta would start with Nashville to stay on rotation.

Relief Pitchers (7)

(with one more starting on DL)

  • Jim Henderson
  • Francisco Rodriguez
  • Will Smith*
  • Brandon Kintzler
  • Wei-Chung Wang*
  • Rob Wooten
  • Alfredo Figaro (Alternative: Tyler Thornburg)
  • Tom Gorzelanny* (DL)

Henderson is the incumbent closer. Rodriguez was brought in on a MLB deal and has the longest track record out of any of the options. Smith has been great this spring after being acquired in trade. Kintzler was very good last year and has a spot locked up. Wang makes it in part because of how well he’s thrown but also because of the Rule V circumstances. Wooten pitched well enough in his time last year that he gets one of my “open” jobs. He’s certainly in a fungible position, though, as he’s got minor league options remaining.

For the final active spot, I’m going with Alfredo Figaro. I know that Tyler Thornburg is under consideration for that job, but I think that they’ll realize that he’s more valuable staying stretched out at Nashville in order to cover the inevitable first injury to the starting rotation than he is in pitching at best every other day in Milwaukee as the long man. Figaro filled the long relief role admirably last year as his stuff played up out of the bullpen.

Wooten, Figaro, and Thornburg all have at least one minor league option remaining so there’s no real consideration of roster depth when making any decisions concering the three. And I think we’ll be seeing all of them pitch at Miller Park in 2014 at one point or another.

As for non-roster invitee Zach Duke, I think that the Brewers have liked what they’ve seen but with Wang making good (so far), there really isn’t room for Duke to begin the season. The veteran lefty is on a minor-league deal, so most likely he’ll simply be assigned to Nashville to start.

Catchers (2)

  • Jonathan Lucroy
  • Martin Maldonado

They’re the only two on the 40-man and that’s because they’re the two best in the organization. Nothing more needs to be said here.

Infielders (7)

  • Mark Reynolds
  • Rickie Weeks
  • Jean Segura
  • Aramis Ramirez
  • Juan Francisco** (Alternative: Lyle Overbay)
  • Scooter Gennett**
  • Jeff Bianchi (Alternative: Elian Herrera)

Reynolds was signed to a minor-league deal for roster considerations at the time. He’s got a job. Weeks is the longest-tenured player in the organization right now and isn’t moveable (yet). Segura and Ramirez are obvious inclusions. Gennett comes along if they go with two second basemen, which has been the hottest talk of late.

Despite all the talk to the contrary lately, I still think that if they must choose between them, Francisco’s potential, relative youth, power, and increased patience this spring outweight Overbay’s veteran savvy, locker room presence, and far superior defense. That said, I can absolutely see a scenario in which they trade Francisco for an asset and keep Overbay. Maybe I’m projecting Francisco simply out of hope.

The other hotly contested job has been the utility infielder role. Jeff Bianchi filled the role last year with middling success. The biggest challenger to Bianchi’s incumbency has been the 40-man rostered Elian Herrera, who was claimed off waivers from the Los Angeles Dodgers over the winter. They’ve both hit, they both have defensive versatility. The differences that matter: Bianchi is a better defender at shortstop. Herrera is a much more natural outfielder (which is big when you’ve only got four rostered). Herrera is a switch hitter. Bianchi is out of options; Herrera has one remaining. It is that last point that I think will be the deciding factor. Herrera will start at Nashville and would absolutley be the first man called upon should an injury befall any infielder on the big league roster.

For the record: Should they decide that they can forego two second basemen to start the year to even the roster out a bit a more, I think Herrera would make the club over a fifth true outfielder.

Outfielders (4)

  • Khris Davis
  • Carlos Gomez
  • Ryan Braun
  • Logan Schafer**

Another easy prediction. Schafer could see some time starting in left field, but as the only man on the projected roster that can backup centerfield, he’ll likely be providing coverage from the bench more often than not.

* - Throws left-handed
** - Bats left-handed

So there you have it.

I welcome feedback and want to hear your opinions. Do you agree? Disagree? Think I’m overlooking an important detail or better player? Look down there…a “Comments” section.


  1. Earl Barker

    Although you say you were projecting Juan Franciso out of hope, you don’t give yourself enough credit. Your words alone (younger, etc) are amble reasons for the Brewers to keep him (hopefully he learned enough defensively watch Lyle this spring).

  2. Ullsperj

    Really well done article!! A lot of insight and thought went into each argument. I couldn’t eager more on your selections either. I think your choices are exactly what we’ll see on opening day.

  3. Nicholas Gallenberg

    Need more info on Woorten, it seems like he’s being handed a gig in the pen. Perhaps Thronburgs the way to go. I dunno. They really need to get what they can for Rickie imo and move forward. They are all in this year and with Reynolds looking good and Herrera looking like a steal as a super utility guy they need to keep Overbay for late inning D and the lack of leadership on O thats been all the talk of camp.

  4. yaphound

    Very well done. I agree with your projections. I thought they would move Rickie during spring, but he’s done very well and apparently no one has been desperate for a 2nd base option and made an attractive offer. Francisco is definitely a project worth continuing to invest in, even if it means letting O go. This is actually a potentially pretty competitive roster all-around.

  5. Jaithjunder@gmail.com

    I know it’s a consensus understanding that Schafer will make the team because of his defensive prowess, but do think there’s any possibility that the Brewers realize that Gindl is probably the better of the two. Gindl’s a couple years younger, Schafer is not major league expectable at the plate, and doesn’t offer anything aside from defensive ability. Now, I understand that is valuable, but seriously, how often does a rookie come up and draw 20 walks to 25 strike outs in his first major league action as Gindl did? That’s pretty rare. Also, Gindl has MUCH more pop. Furthermore, looking into Gindl’s minor league career, he is seriously AOKi-like against left handed hitting, whereas Schafer literally looked like a little league kid against lefties last year. Aside from all this, i really think a lefty that has a great eye and solid pop is a guy that profiles very well as a pinch hitter. At the end of the day, Melvin hardly ever values defense (Reynolds, Francisco, WEEKS, Davis), so why do you think all of a sudden he thinks a guy who probably wont even log 60 defensive games this year is so important to the team when he can’t even buy a hit and all he offers is defense? How much can Gindl’s defense really hurt the team in a backup role?

    • Brewer Nation

      It’s about being able to play MLB CF defensively which Gindl can’t do. If they were carrying five OFs, Gindl would be among them. They know Gindl has more offensive potential than does Schafer.

  6. Jaithjunder@gmail.com

    By the way, sorry to fill up so much space, but if Wooten makes this team over Figaro, that should be considered criminal. Guys who throw low fastballs at 94-98 and even 99 mph, and hardly walk anyone, don’t come around too often. If he gets his breaking ball consistent, which it looked pretty wicked in a game last week, I think he could seriously turn into a MLB closer. Thanks for your work and thoughts.

  7. Pingback: Trout, Hamilton homer as Angles beat Brewers 9-6 | Betting Baseball Club

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s